Key Takeaways
- Expect 15–35% above a comparable homeowners policy — carriers price tenant risk.
- Typical ranges: $900–$1,400 low-risk single family, $1,300–$1,800 national average, $1,800–$3,500+ short-term rentals.
- The levers that actually work: deductible strategy, carrier competition, portfolio pricing, and risk credits.
- “Cheap” done wrong is a DP-1 with no loss of rents — cheap done right is the same coverage at a shopped price.
Our domain name makes a promise, so let’s keep it honestly: this is what landlord insurance actually costs, why, and the specific levers that bring the number down without thinning the coverage. No teaser rates, no “from $9/month” theater.
Real ranges
| Scenario | Typical annual range |
|---|---|
| Single-family, long-term tenant, low-risk state | $900 – $1,400 |
| National average, long-term rental | $1,300 – $1,800 |
| Coastal / hail-belt / older property | $1,800 – $3,000+ |
| Short-term rental / Airbnb | $1,800 – $3,500+ |
| Portfolio (per property, at scale) | Often 10–25% below one-off pricing |
The 15–35% premium over homeowners is structural — more claims frequency, more liability traffic, less owner eyes-on-the-property. You can’t argue it away, but you can absolutely out-shop it.
What moves your number up
- State and ZIP — hail belts, hurricanes, litigation climates
- Roof age — the single most-asked question in property underwriting
- Year built and systems — electrical, plumbing, HVAC updates matter more than the build year
- Claims history — yours and the property’s
- Occupancy type — short-term rentals price higher (why, explained)
- Liability traffic — pools, hot tubs, steep stairs, certain dog breeds
- Coverage choices — limits, deductible, endorsements, and the DP form
The levers that bring it down
- Deductible strategy. A rental is a business asset — carry $2,500–$5,000 deductibles, self-insure small stuff, and let the premium credit compound. Usually the biggest single lever.
- Carrier competition. Every carrier prices rentals differently; the same house can quote 40% apart. This is the entire argument for a broker — we make them compete.
- Portfolio pricing. Two or more properties usually beat one-off policies (how portfolio programs work).
- Risk credits. New roof, water sensors, monitored alarms, documented tenant screening — carriers pay you back for being a good operator.
- Annual re-shop. Rental markets move; loyalty rarely pays. We re-shop at renewal by default.
Ready for a real number? Enter your address and get an instant price indication — no waiting on a callback.
Where not to save
Two cuts that look like savings and behave like losses: dropping to a DP-1 form (depreciated payouts on a short peril list) and skipping loss of rents (the coverage you feel within weeks of a real claim). If a quote comes in suspiciously cheap, one of those two is usually why. That’s not cheap — that’s pre-paying for a bad day.
Landlord insurance cost FAQ
Why is landlord insurance more expensive than homeowners?
What’s the single biggest lever to lower my premium?
Do short-term rentals really cost that much more to insure?
Will one claim spike my premium?
Ready for a real number? Enter your address and get an instant price indication — no waiting on a callback.